Item 1:
A woman walked into the kitchen to find her husband walking around with a fly swatter.
“What are you doing?” she asked.
“Hunting flies,” He responded.
“Oh, killing any?” She asked.
“Yep, three males, two females,” he replied.
Intrigued, she asked, “How can you tell?”
He responded, “Three were on a beer can, two were on the phone.”
Source: http://www.tienganh123.com/hoc-tieng-anh-qua-truyen-cuoi/7002-flies.html
=> Appeals to belief
The man believes that all the male like beer and all the female like chatting with phone. So do the flies.
Item 2:
Source: http://alexshye.wordpress.com/2012/09/21/beware-of-false-dichotomies-goals-vs-love/
Analysis: the picture shows that a man just has two doors to go in; they are “fulfillment without wealth” or “wealth without fulfillment”. Therefore he has to choose one of these two ways, either the first door or the second one.
=> Fallacies of presumption: false dilemma: He maybe has more than two ways to select such as both wealth and fulfillment or neither fulfillment or wealth but happiness.
Item 3: Video Pond's
slippery slope
Pond’s => white beauty => romantic life.
In fact, there are many way to have a white beauty skin, you can use hog-wash, much more natural. In order to have a romantic life, just a rose of the husband after a working long day can make their life romantic.
“What are you doing?” she asked.
“Hunting flies,” He responded.
“Oh, killing any?” She asked.
“Yep, three males, two females,” he replied.
Intrigued, she asked, “How can you tell?”
He responded, “Three were on a beer can, two were on the phone.”
Source: http://www.tienganh123.com/hoc-tieng-anh-qua-truyen-cuoi/7002-flies.html
=> Appeals to belief
The man believes that all the male like beer and all the female like chatting with phone. So do the flies.
Item 2:
Source: http://alexshye.wordpress.com/2012/09/21/beware-of-false-dichotomies-goals-vs-love/
Analysis: the picture shows that a man just has two doors to go in; they are “fulfillment without wealth” or “wealth without fulfillment”. Therefore he has to choose one of these two ways, either the first door or the second one.
=> Fallacies of presumption: false dilemma: He maybe has more than two ways to select such as both wealth and fulfillment or neither fulfillment or wealth but happiness.
Item 3: Video Pond's
slippery slope
Pond’s => white beauty => romantic life.
In fact, there are many way to have a white beauty skin, you can use hog-wash, much more natural. In order to have a romantic life, just a rose of the husband after a working long day can make their life romantic.
Hong: I think you forgot to copy the source in item 2 and 3.
Trả lờiXóaBesides, in the item 3, I think it isn't slippery slope. In my opinion, it's Fallacy of necessary and sufficient of conditions. Pond can make you beautiful but it not enough to make a romantic life :) Just my opinion, hihi.
I also think in Item 3, it is Fallacy of necessary and sufficient of conditions. Pond's can make you beautiful that is necessary condition and in order to make a romantic life it need a sufficient condition.
Trả lờiXóaYou should add sources in item 2 and 3. In item 1, I think it is the fallacy of relevance(appeal to popularity). Some people think that all the male are related to beer can and all the female are related to phone. So do the flies.
Trả lờiXóaThanks for all opinions!
Trả lờiXóa